Possibly a Penzel Mueller full Boehm in A

Started by mechanic, May 12, 2017, 10:24:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mechanic

The logo's on this one are mostly gone, but what bits remain have me thinking it may be a Penzel Mueller.  It's marked L.P., A and the serial is 7214 and all easy to pick out.  Matching serial number on both joints.  I think I see the outline of the eagles wings below the A on the upper joint, or my eyes are going buggy. 
For Phil's  " The Clarinet Pages " forum. https://clarinetpages.info/

mechanic

For Phil's  " The Clarinet Pages " forum. https://clarinetpages.info/

mechanic

For Phil's  " The Clarinet Pages " forum. https://clarinetpages.info/

Silversorcerer

- Hollowed backs on some of the keys.  Those keys were used by Penzel Mueller, Pruefer (during the partnership) and curiously also by Moennig in Germany. The keys of the Bb sopranos are interchangeable between makers. The metal is pretty soft and the hollowed key backs didn't catch on. These hollowed key models were made either during WW1 (when PM partnered with Pruefer) or in the few years after. We do have a serial date with a sales receipt from 1927 and that places this one mid 1920s. The earliest A that we know of so far that was serialized (before WW1 about there are no serials) was number 3338.

There are a few A PM's in the serial list and I have seen some earlier ones that were not serialized. For some reason these seem to not be as rare as A clarinets by some of the other makers. Phil has an A also. It would be interesting for these two to be compared pretty soon. How tall is the barrel on this one?
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Silversorcerer

I think Dave restored one of these recently. That is another one that would be interesting to compare. It would be most interesting if we could get the measurements of the parts of all three of these A models. Phil's, this one and the one Dave restored. I'd love to see all three side by side. There was good deal of variation on the approach to the 7th ring in the 1920s at PM. This might be the 3rd different way of doing it I've seen. There also was a phenomenon between the barrel length and the upper joint length changing for a few years as the LP B finally becomes the Artist. All of these from the 1920s are very interesting because it is a transitional period. Even models with very close serials can have differently dimensioned parts. Check this photo of the changing barrels and uppers. The distance from barrel top to register vent remains constant while the proportion shifts. I'd like to know if that was also going on with the A models. Now we have 3 sort of in one place that we can measure.

This is definitely a Penzel Mueller in all details. The way they built the wrap around register key (but I have seen more typical spirals on a few), the hollowed key backs, the serial number and the locations of these;- no question of the provenance. If there were no feathers at all, the entirety of the form is screaming Penzel Mueller. Sharp eyes to catch the eagle's wing though. The serial is too late, but the only other maker that might look like that was Pruefer for a very short time after the partnership ceased. Penzel Muellers and Pruefers of that period are indistinguishable without some vestige of the marks or a serial beyond 4000. Serial 3795? There are two of those. One is a PMP and the other a PM. I am sure that for a few years even the serials on Pruefers and PMs must have followed the same sequence. Then both companies introduced Artist models about the same time.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

mechanic

The barrel with this one is 65.3mm.

The Moennig connection is also interesting.  This A came to me in a box of clarinet parts.  In sorting out the parts, there was a complete Moennig Brother Bb full Boehm as well.  The Moennig also has the hollowed key touches, but sports a straight register key.  No serial on the Moennig.

Top of the barrel to middle of the register vent is 94 mm.

For Phil's  " The Clarinet Pages " forum. https://clarinetpages.info/

Silversorcerer

Great. I hope Dave still has the one he restored and we can check the measurements. Phil has changed the barrel on his but might still have the original. We suspect it might have been a substitute anyway because he reported egregious intonation. If yours is all original, which it certainly appears to be with an A barrel mark, then we have that critical sum of the barrel and upper joint measurement. That was what is original on the A models. It's the baseline and evaluating the intonation of one of these against an A=435 LP standard could be informative. Evaluating an all original full Boehm A model could be most informative. I don't believe we had a true A=440 Penzel Mueller until the Artist model appeared. These change incrementally from the LP models over a number of years and suddenly one morning they wake up marked as Artist models.

You see though that these barrels, even when from the same makers at about the same time are not interchangeable. That longest barrel in my photo is 69.9mm. That is on a Pruefer Bb 7-ring #2410 from around the partnership point. probably just before it. The other two are a PMP and a PM. From the patina on the keys and other rings, the barrels certainly all appear to be the originals on those three.

There is another curious character to the keys on these PMs and I see hints of it on yours as well. Some of the key parts are different colored metal that also takes a higher polish, perhaps even plated. Do you notice that on yours? I can see it in the photos, was looking for it because I see it on the Penzel Muellers that I have that are from about that time. There are original parts of keys that shine up with a higher shine and appear to be either plated or made of a whiter metal than the rest of the key work. The first one of these I looked at I thought there had been some very well done key repairs and substitutions. Then I saw photos of more of these that looked the same way. I don't know why or if it was deliberate or because of some shortage of metal or what, but the PMs and PMPs of this era have two-tone keys. Look at the LJ ring key in the middle. From left to right these are a PMP WW1 era, a PM post WW1, and a Pruefer pre-WW1. Those PM rings stick out like. Other keys also have the two tone look. Do you notice that on your A? Look for it.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Silversorcerer

The key arms that cross over the rods on the lower joints is another place where PM used that higher shine metal. Check those on your A in the photo that shows these. Those key arms are a different metal surface than the rods and pad cups that are attached to them. It's not always the rings. Where I have seen this, it is generally both the rings and some of the key arms. It isn't all the parts of a single key anywhere. That is one of the most curious features I have ever seen on any group of clarinets. On these PMs of this era, if the polish of the metal is done by light hand polishing only, the result is a very subtle two-tone appearance. Even the illustrations in advertisements that are not photographs of these tend to depict this two-toned key look.

That is a very interesting and quite rare A clarinet with the sum of its' features. Is it playable? I'd really like to hear / see what the original tuning is like.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Silversorcerer

One very curious detail on your A I noticed earlier, forgot to mention is that it appears to have alignment marks on the LJ socket ring and in the UJ wood;- three dots on both (your photo showing serial #). I see this and wonder if this was added by a player or if it might have been original. Those rows of dots don't appear to be random marks.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

DaveLeBlanc

I have 2 full Boehm A clarinets:
A one-piece mostly-plateau donut-keyed Buffet:
http://www.clarinetpages.net/vintage-odd-brands/buffet/full-plateau-buffet-with-donut-key

And a Rudolph Gottsman with French rollers down under:
https://sites.google.com/a/clarinetpages.net/www/vintage-odd-brands/rudolf-gottsman-full-boehm-a

I'm not sure if these will be much help, measurement-wise, especially since the Buffet is unibody!
David Watson of the original The Clarinet Pages
Virginia Beach, Virginia

modernicus

#10
Quote from: DaveLeBlanc on May 15, 2017, 05:31:00 PM
I have 2 full Boehm A clarinets:
A one-piece mostly-plateau donut-keyed Buffet:
http://www.clarinetpages.net/vintage-odd-brands/buffet/full-plateau-buffet-with-donut-key

And a Rudolph Gottsman with French rollers down under:
https://sites.google.com/a/clarinetpages.net/www/vintage-odd-brands/rudolf-gottsman-full-boehm-a

I'm not sure if these will be much help, measurement-wise, especially since the Buffet is unibody!

If the Gottsman is like my Nuernberger, the key metal is harder than you'd find on other clarinets, and seemingly likely to break rather than bend, judging by all these (poor) repairs.  Anyway, it also happens to have the hollowed out key backs.  Weight or material conservation? Who knows.   BTW,  like I mentioned before,  I still think that Buffet is more like 1860s-1880s era. 8)
If you ain't got 'em, that's why you need 'em...

DaveLeBlanc

Quote from: modernicus on May 15, 2017, 07:15:09 PM
Quote from: DaveLeBlanc on May 15, 2017, 05:31:00 PM
I have 2 full Boehm A clarinets:
A one-piece mostly-plateau donut-keyed Buffet:
http://www.clarinetpages.net/vintage-odd-brands/buffet/full-plateau-buffet-with-donut-key

And a Rudolph Gottsman with French rollers down under:
https://sites.google.com/a/clarinetpages.net/www/vintage-odd-brands/rudolf-gottsman-full-boehm-a

I'm not sure if these will be much help, measurement-wise, especially since the Buffet is unibody!
BTW,  like I mentioned before,  I still think that Buffet is more like 1860s-1880s era. 8)
Thanks, I'll update it!
David Watson of the original The Clarinet Pages
Virginia Beach, Virginia

Silversorcerer

#12
I thought that you had restored or were restoring an A full Boehm Penzel Mueller, Dave. I made a note in the PM serial list, # 6839. I guess I am confused. I thought it was an A, if that is a mistake I should correct it.

I think the measurements of any unibody clarinet, especially with the barrel incorporated, would be extremely informative about the particular maker, perhaps all the makers of the same era. Nothing can be adjusted in length and nothing can be substituted. All the specifications are aimed at the ideal design. If we are trying to find the ideally scaled artifact, a single tube is as close as we might get to it.

When we look at a specific maker's design changes, we might need a few of a type in close sequence to see the trend in the way the parts are scaled. We can't assume a 70mm barrel is a long barrel if the clarinet it belongs to has a shorter upper joint.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

modernicus

Quote from: DaveLeBlanc on May 15, 2017, 09:24:47 PM
Quote from: modernicus on May 15, 2017, 07:15:09 PM
Quote from: DaveLeBlanc on May 15, 2017, 05:31:00 PM
I have 2 full Boehm A clarinets:
A one-piece mostly-plateau donut-keyed Buffet:
http://www.clarinetpages.net/vintage-odd-brands/buffet/full-plateau-buffet-with-donut-key

And a Rudolph Gottsman with French rollers down under:
https://sites.google.com/a/clarinetpages.net/www/vintage-odd-brands/rudolf-gottsman-full-boehm-a

I'm not sure if these will be much help, measurement-wise, especially since the Buffet is unibody!
BTW,  like I mentioned before,  I still think that Buffet is more like 1860s-1880s era. 8)
Thanks, I'll update it!
That's my opinion.  There is no serial number,  correct?   They didn't start serializing until 1885.  There isn't very much information on early Boehm clarinets, unfortunately.  Buffet Crampon themselves weren't helpful to me with dating their instruments pre-serial number,  either.  It's my belief that any Buffets with plated brass keywork are very early, say prior to the 1880s.  There are Buffets in that timeframe with unplated brass keywork, especially appearing in boxwood.  Commercial nickel plating became viable late 1850s, I believe.  We know the enhanced Boehm features go back to the 1850s at least since I have one, and I've seen information, like on the Boehm clarinet Wikipedia entry, asserting that Buffet Crampon pioneered the full Boehm around the 1870s.  Not sure about unibodies timeframe,  but definitely by 1886, since I have one of those. So my guess,  circa 1870s...
If you ain't got 'em, that's why you need 'em...

mechanic

Quote from: Silversorcerer on May 13, 2017, 09:21:18 AM
The key arms that cross over the rods on the lower joints is another place where PM used that higher shine metal. Check those on your A in the photo that shows these. Those key arms are a different metal surface than the rods and pad cups that are attached to them. It's not always the rings. Where I have seen this, it is generally both the rings and some of the key arms. It isn't all the parts of a single key anywhere. That is one of the most curious features I have ever seen on any group of clarinets. On these PMs of this era, if the polish of the metal is done by light hand polishing only, the result is a very subtle two-tone appearance. Even the illustrations in advertisements that are not photographs of these tend to depict this two-toned key look.

That is a very interesting and quite rare A clarinet with the sum of its' features. Is it playable? I'd really like to hear / see what the original tuning is like.

This one is still in as it came out of the box condition.  I did oil the bore right away and a couple more times since.  The register key and Eb  pads are missing, and quite a few others look like they've been chewed on. 

I think you are correct that the keys have different metals, and sometimes on the same key.  Most of the keys on this have that dull hazy look with a fair amount of green funk going on.  The pad cup on the register key, the touch pieces on the top 2 trill keys, the pad cup on the Eb, the touch piece and arm on the C# and the crossovers on the lower joint all look recently polished.

Quote from: Silversorcerer on May 13, 2017, 09:44:46 AM
One very curious detail on your A I noticed earlier, forgot to mention is that it appears to have alignment marks on the LJ socket ring and in the UJ wood;- three dots on both (your photo showing serial #). I see this and wonder if this was added by a player or if it might have been original. Those rows of dots don't appear to be random marks.

I assumed they were alignment marks, but it's hard to tell if they are original or added.  I'm leaning towards owner added because they don't form a straight line.  Top joint marks go down and angle slightly right, and the lowers go down and angle slightly left.  A 170 degree angle I suppose.  The Bb has what looks like the head of a finishing nail embedded in the wood on each joint for alignment.
For Phil's  " The Clarinet Pages " forum. https://clarinetpages.info/