Harry Pedler 175A Eb Alto

Started by Silversorcerer, August 23, 2017, 08:24:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Silversorcerer

This is my first alto clarinet. When I was learning jazz tunes on my Bb soprano, I realized that quite a few of these lead lines I was reading were a bit awkward and seemed displaced in some passages. Thinking about the recordings these lines were transcribed from I realized that these were probably transcribed from alto saxophone lead lines, then scored for Bb. These might sound truer to form played on an alto clarinet than a soprano, I decided.

I began looking for an alto clarinet that fit my generally nonexistent budget, and after missing several, finally won this antiquated Harry Pedler model 175A (The "A" designates that it plays low Eb on the bell key, the 175 is the model plays E on the bell key). Accessories included the original case in great condition, the marching lyre, and the metal mouthpiece cover. No mouthpiece.

This alto model was presumably available for about a decade when Harry Pedler was completely in control of his company, beyond his partnership with Gronert and before his brief partnership with Martin Band Instrument Company. An alto Harry Pedler is a model that is seldom seen;- genuine Harry Pedler sopranos and basses are rare enough.

Most of the Pedler altos and basses we see are the Custom-built model that debuted after Pedler became part of MBIC. These instruments are completely redesigned consistent with later features and more complex mechanics.

If this one had a mouthpiece, I think it would have played as it came, but it needed a good bit of optimization to make it play well. While I waited for a mouthpiece to materialize, I got the optimization underway. Like many antique instruments, it's service history included an accumulation of errors and half measures among some more professional repairs. I spent about 3 days cleaning it up, tightening up a few posts and limiting the key action everywhere with fresh corks as needed.

It has tan leather pads new and old, and I'll use similar when I replace any. The pads look like the same type that are on my 201A bass model of the same era.

Whenever I get one of these USA built ancient relics (circa 1925), and go over the mechanics, I'm impressed with the care and precision of the original manufacturer that is evident in every detail. All of the parts are high quality, no shortcuts taken, and the whole is the sum of the parts. Harry Pedler instruments were not that fancy, well, until you start looking at the sheer elegance of form and fit. It goes beyond the audacious bell engraving which Harry might have inherited from C.G. Conn.

The pivot screws are not the pointed type, but rather a screw with a short rod attached to it. This positions the key rods very positively. It also means that post alignment is critical. If expansion and contraction have loosened the posts, those need to be tightened up.

The keys are solid nickel-silver, soft enough to be adjusted where needed without breaking but hard enough not to bend under normal use. Springs were blued needle springs, most of them in good enough shape to remain in service.

The wood is very dark rosewood (as reported in the brochure) and this is obviously a wood that is a good bit less dense than grenadilla. The joints feel lighter than they look. It's not a heavy clarinet until the bell and neck are added and it is still lighter than it looks.

One previous repair that was very well accomplished was the replacement of the LJ F# key cup with what looks like a silver-plated sax cup. It's not something that jumps out at a glance, and it's so perfectly fixed to the rod that it looks like factory solder work.

So how does it sound? I can't get a note out of it without the mouthpiece!  ::)

There are not many reviews of Harry Pedler alto clarinets. The discussion I could find is primarily for the Custom-built model that followed the 175A and was a Martin Band Instrument Co. product, and it seems that the owner had not ever faced up to having the keys properly serviced, and blamed the instrument's performance on being worn out. Such is the type of review that indicates an instrument being judged while in poor condition. Big surprise that an instrument in poor condition has issues?

Before I discuss how this one sounds, it will have been brought into at least optimum mechanical condition. It will feel tight and solid under the fingertips. How well an instrument is set up makes a huge difference in how well it plays and older instruments that have never been totally rebuilt probably do not have very carefully set clearances and key motion limits. This one Is getting all the tweaks and corrections.

Feature limitations due to era of construction:
1) Left thumb and LH 4 ( C ) plateaus, 5 open holes.
2) Manual double register keys

Desirable features:
1) open holes for note bending
2) Eb bell key
3) Mechanics are as simple as a full Boehm Bb soprano.

A few photos:
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

LarryS

You don't stop playing when you get old, you get old when you stop playing.
My music blog:
https://mymusictree.blogspot.com/


Clarinet Pages are go!

DaveLeBlanc

I've never seen a manufacturer with prettier bells than Pedler.
David Watson of the original The Clarinet Pages
Virginia Beach, Virginia

Windsong

Gorgious!  And a great report.

Now, to find you a suitable MP...
Perhaps contact J.J. Babbitt?  They will surely be able aid in the procurement of exactly what you need (whether it be through manufacture of a new piece based upon historical facings, or sourcing of a NOS piece) and are extremely knowledgable folks. 
Expert bubblegum welder, and Pedler Pedler.

Silversorcerer

Quote from: DaveLeBlanc on August 24, 2017, 02:06:19 PM
I've never seen a manufacturer with prettier bells than Pedler.

This is a detail of the 175A engraving from the Pedler serial thread. This is the stye before the silver plated art deco engraved bells of the Custom-built series.


Windsong, I know it will be nearly impossible to find an original Harry Pedler alto mouthpiece. I also know that the Geo. M. Bundy #3 vintage piece fit the socket on the 201A and plays pretty well and a later Selmer mouthpiece did not fit. It seems like it will be safer to keep an eye out for something vintage.

You pointed out earlier that the original Harry Pedler mouthpieces were probably J.J. Babbitts of some stripe. I'm guessing that a vintage J.J. Babbitt will be easier to find than a Harry Pedler, and a Geo. M. Bundy would make a good back-up piece. Maybe I'll get lucky.  ;)

- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Windsong

Yes, indeed.  I'll keep my eyes out for you on all fronts.

That detail on the bell is just fantastic.  Literally just as good as the best I've seen from any manufacturer.  It's deep, precise and artful.  Hand engraving as a truly lost art.  All engraving nowadays is stale, and far too uniform for my tastes. 

Such a shame that we, as a global society have no use for real art anymore.  The truth is that you'd probably pay an appropriately compensated artisan upwards of $350.00-$500.00 to engrave a bell like that nowadays, and few people are willing to pay for an ornamental upgrade, when a machine can do it for $50.00 (and they will all be identical).
Expert bubblegum welder, and Pedler Pedler.

Silversorcerer

You never know how different things might have been had C.G. Conn not been a member of the Platers and Engravers union. There were some other makers of that time doing very fancy engravings, but Conn set a style and pattern that was general, but no two horns were ever exactly alike. I think that Harry Pedler brought that with him from Conn. The style of this 1919 silver cornet bell is very much like the Harry Pedler.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Airflyte

Quote from: Windsong on August 24, 2017, 03:18:31 PM
Yes, indeed.  I'll keep my eyes out for you on all fronts.

That detail on the bell is just fantastic.  Literally just as good as the best I've seen from any manufacturer.  It's deep, precise and artful.  Hand engraving as a truly lost art.  All engraving nowadays is stale, and far too uniform for my tastes. 

Such a shame that we, as a global society have no use for real art anymore.  The truth is that you'd probably pay an appropriately compensated artisan upwards of $350.00-$500.00 to engrave a bell like that nowadays, and few people are willing to pay for an ornamental upgrade, when a machine can do it for $50.00 (and they will all be identical).

I have seen a "Log Cabin" Conn gold plate alto sax and it was incredible - pictures do no justice to the level of quality.
"The Clarinet - in a class of its own"

Visit Phil Pedler's Clarinet Pages NEW website!
https://sites.google.com/clarinetpages.net/clarinetpages

Silversorcerer

Some of the less obvious but more critical re-build detail work:
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Silversorcerer

Searching everywhere anywhere for other information on a Harry Pedler alto model comes up dry. The scarcity of discussion belies the rarity of the object and thus I feel compelled to discuss this example in depth.

Quite a bit of the discussion of similar alto models by different manufacturers also applies to Harry Pedler model 175A, because it is primarily an open hole alto design and if these are notorious for anything, it is the difficulty of the wide finger spacing that results from the necessary length of the instrument. Generally these discussions are about the alto designs taken separately from the context of the sister bass models. In that context, it is indeed easy (and correct) to regard these as challenging for players that come to the alto instrument from an open hole Bb soprano.

If however, one compares the open hole alto design to the sister plateau bass design, the fingering challenge appears far less daunting.

In that I have managed quite by providence to acquire this model 175A as well as a Harry Pedler late full plateau 201A bass, I have the opportunity to present the ergonomic compatibility of these two side by side in 4 photographs.

The left hand that is accustomed to fingering a bass 201A has only a little bit of extra distance to get used to to play the 175A alto. The attempt by Harry Pedler to design the two as similarly as possible is quite obvious. Put down one, pick up the other and there are few surprises for the fingers. The rather broad and flat surfaces of the upper joint rings reflects an attempt to make it easier to cover the tone holes without interference from the rings. It is worth noting that earlier 201A bass models retained one ring for the left hand F# tone hole on the upper joint;- an early 201A would even be more similar in feel.

The most obviously advantageous plateau key for an alto is the left thumb, particularly if the alto requires calisthenics related to manual double register keys. It is also without mechanical complication to add a plateau to the C tone hole that isn't linked to any other keys. So that is where Harry Pedler put the plateaus;- in positions that would most facilitate playing and least complicate the mechanism.

Regarding the right hand, while no plateaus have been added, it is also obvious that the locations of the touch pieces for the keys have been made to be as similar as possible between the 201A and 175A.

The thumb rest positions are quite curious and not analogous, and it is apparent that the reason for this is that with the bass model the position of the right arm is a good bit lower than with the alto and the position of the thumb rest has moved up relative to the fingers to allow for the more downward orientation of the right hand.

In total, if one is accustomed to playing a bass 201A, one has a head start adjusting to an alto 175A.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Lisa

I'm absolutely green with jealously!  If I had seen it, I would of ended up in a bidding war with you, so I'm glad in a way that didn't happen.
If you see another one, let me know.  I'm also interested in an open hole also.  The 175A covers all the bases for me, thanks for posting such great info on it.
Lisa
Lisa  Upper Michigan

Everything will B(b)-Fine, at The Clarinet Pages

https://www.flickr.com/photos/148152785@N03/albums  My musical instrument pics, and others!

Silversorcerer

Quote from: Lisa on September 14, 2017, 09:33:11 AM
I'm absolutely green with jealously!  If I had seen it, I would of ended up in a bidding war with you, so I'm glad in a way that didn't happen.
If you see another one, let me know.  I'm also interested in an open hole also.  The 175A covers all the bases for me, thanks for posting such great info on it.
Lisa

I actually read your thread and measured my reach before I bid on it.  :)
I thought you probably already found one. This one needed (and got) tons of work and still needs a little more to get it to its' full potential.

I probably would have bid anyway (and I bid significantly higher than what I got it for), but FYI, my reach is about the same as yours, with my left having a distinct stretch advantage from many years playing bass guitar and double bass fiddle. You can take that as indicative that an open hole will work fine for your hands. My right is a bit less than yours from thumb tip to pinkie tip.

Bettoney also made a similar design that might be less rare. That would be a fun one to compare to the Harry type. I'll keep my eyes peeled for another one.

I wound up buying a package deal of 4 mouthpieces to try. So far a Geo. M. Bundy #3 works better than a Selmer HS* or a Selmer D. The Babbitt Artist was radically re-faced by Joe Vasallo and I have to do some I reed experiments to know what the custom facing does. It's wide open at the tip.

I'm also using a G.M. Bundy for by bass Harry Pedler, so it's a familiar feel. I might keep one of the Selmers. The D seems like it might be to late a type for this clarinet. The HS* works OK depending on the reed.
- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

Lisa

I think it went to the proper home, as I've got a fleet of clarinets waiting for me to get brave and fix them.  I'm glad you have the knowledge to fix it and play it, it looks like it's got a lot of soul, if that makes any sense. 

I've got some clarinets that are nothing special, an old student pan am that would be a good practice victim for me, then I'd like to work on a resonite Cousenon & Cie Albert Bb that kind of plays.  What it does play, sounds smoooth, like buttah!  Almost dead on in tune, to boot!

Right now, I'm madly in love with a no name key of C clarinet, albert/simple system with four rings.  i have two fabric pony tail hair ties around two pad cups to hold them down tighter so I can play it, that's how technical I am.  I did take a dremel tool to a small Bb mouthpiece and buzz it down so it fits in the barrel of the C, but found it's a bit too flat, and will have to search out some vintage Eb ones with the string lines on them.  That's what it came with, and that's what it likes.
Anyhow, I'm also glad you think my mitts would work on an open hole, I've got big hands, and big flat fingers too, no dainty, pointy fingertips.  My dad used to say I had hands like a lumberjack.  I guess you're probably a member of the lumberjack hand club too.
Lisa
Lisa  Upper Michigan

Everything will B(b)-Fine, at The Clarinet Pages

https://www.flickr.com/photos/148152785@N03/albums  My musical instrument pics, and others!

Silversorcerer

Until I can replace one of the blued needle springs, the Harry alto is using a pony tail circle to close the top register key. It works.

The original had been bent severely to compensate for a rotated post, which didn't work of course, and left the brittle rusted spring vulnerable when I locked the post properly. So it will get the new spring next week, after I find a good source among the many.

Rotating posts were chronic and none of the attempts to fix that in the past were effective. Two posts had notches filed in the collars and needles (broken off spring ends) driven into the body through the notches. Of course that didn't work and those "nails" had to be removed.

Locking the posts properly was done by wrapping sewing thread around the post threads under the collars to increase the friction and pressure between the post collar and the body wood. That works every time I've done it. If some repair procedure appears to be difficult or ugly, there's probably a better way.

This alto was a really good instrument and can be, but it was down to good bones in need of serious R&R.

I am also putting in some time on a C simple, two rings only. It is a Couesnon and also likes it's original wooden MP. It looks to be the same dimension as the typical Bb MP, but for some reason those don't work so well. The C without so many keys is pretty light weight compared to a Bb Boehm.

The simple system with less rings is a great instrument to do as a first restoration because there is less to mess with and fewer needle springs, less pads to replace. The C Couesnon got the works, totally new white kangaroo pads, new corks top to bottom. Even after It was playable I spent several weeks tweaking the key action. It's now tight enough to be dependable.

Between it and the Harry alto I am staying confused. I've been putting in about an hour a day on each. Play one until water comes out the bell;- dry it out and play the other one until water comes out the bell.

Then I go back to a Bb Boehm or alternatively the Pedler bass. Never a dull moment lately.  :)

- Silversorcerer (David Powell) exclusively for Phil's original “The Clarinet Pages" forum

DaveLeBlanc

Quote from: Silversorcerer on September 16, 2017, 09:02:06 PM
Until I can replace one of the blued needle springs, the Harry alto is using a pony tail circle to close the top register key. It works.

The original had been bent severely to compensate for a rotated post, which didn't work of course, and left the brittle rusted spring vulnerable when I locked the post properly. So it will get the new spring next week, after I find a good source among the many.

Rotating posts were chronic and none of the attempts to fix that in the past were effective. Two posts had notches filed in the collars and needles (broken off spring ends) driven into the body through the notches. Of course that didn't work and those "nails" had to be removed.

Locking the posts properly was done by wrapping sewing thread around the post threads under the collars to increase the friction and pressure between the post collar and the body wood. That works every time I've done it. If some repair procedure appears to be difficult or ugly, there's probably a better way.

This alto was a really good instrument and can be, but it was down to good bones in need of serious R&R.

I am also putting in some time on a C simple, two rings only. It is a Couesnon and also likes it's original wooden MP. It looks to be the same dimension as the typical Bb MP, but for some reason those don't work so well. The C without so many keys is pretty light weight compared to a Bb Boehm.

The simple system with less rings is a great instrument to do as a first restoration because there is less to mess with and fewer needle springs, less pads to replace. The C Couesnon got the works, totally new white kangaroo pads, new corks top to bottom. Even after It was playable I spent several weeks tweaking the key action. It's now tight enough to be dependable.

Between it and the Harry alto I am staying confused. I've been putting in about an hour a day on each. Play one until water comes out the bell;- dry it out and play the other one until water comes out the bell.

Then I go back to a Bb Boehm or alternatively the Pedler bass. Never a dull moment lately.  :)
Well if you just need a single needle spring, then maybe try these absurdly expensive gold plated ones from Music Medic :)
http://musicmedic.com/products/repair-supplies/springs/gold-plated-needle-springs.html
David Watson of the original The Clarinet Pages
Virginia Beach, Virginia