Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Silversorcerer

#1366
I agree that it is just a design stamp. It's on 4 Cabart clarinets I have collected, the oldest an early Albert, the next one marked "LP B", and two others past the 1920 elimination of "HP" manufacture.
#1367
I saw the record of this auction recently, along with the photo of the bill of sale. It is a wonderful thing this instrument has made it into public awareness. If I remember correctly, this is serial #9934, a five ring Albert.

The importance of this dated sales receipt for a new instrument can hardly be understated. Before this artifact appeared, the general production dates of PM clarinets was difficult or impossible to closely estimate, complicated by the fact that sometime during production, the serialization code method changed.

This receipt gives us a pretty dependable stake in the time sequence at the company. There are a few things now that we can apply to answering the date question of any given serial number. We know when the company started making them (1899), we know the date within several months of the making of #9934 (1927) and we know when the company ceased production around 1956.

Add to that the surviving records of advertisements in periodicals and several surviving instruments with "US" marking on them that identifies them with a range of years around WW2, and we now have a very good estimate of when these instruments were built based on serial number.

Additionally I should mention that I have it from the seller of an early A (spiral register key) Penzel Mueller that was recently for sale, that it had no serial that he could find anywhere. Serialization then might have commenced some time into the production.

I have already discussed with the administrator of the Penzel Mueller Fan page pooling a list of known instruments and serial numbers. I have been collecting images and serial numbers of ones at auction and I have about a dozen Penzel Muellers in my own collection. If we can collect enough serial numbers, then we can tighten up our time table of serial ranges.

In my efforts, here are some things that seem apparent by observation. The first serial sequence is a simple number sequence. Therefore by about 1930, around 10,000 instruments had been built. This serial sequence system was used until at least the middle to late 1930s with numbers going higher than # 17000. It was still in place after the Artist model name was in use. Then the serial format changed and about the same time, more models were introduced.

The letter prefixes were added and the numbers started over again. For instance, my H127B is an Empire. I have seen several Empire serial records and all of them have the H prefix. So what I have is the 127th clarinet of the second serial series and it is an H model, an Empire, and it is a Bb clarinet (the B suffix).

Some of the Artist models in the second serial series have an "M" prefix, others have an "L". All of the Brilliante models I have record of have the "M" prefix. It thus appears that until the Brilliante was introduced, the Artist had the "M" prefix, and then became the "L" when the Brilliant took the top model slot and also the "M" prefix. Super Brilliantes have the prefix "SM".

If we look at the bulk of the instruments that are stamped "US", indicating manufacture for military use, these are in the (X)6000 - (X)8000 range. It is most plausible that this is the range of production around WW2.

The highest serial I have on record is my own H15208B, a later Empire, and it thus appears that this is a late 40s or early 50s model, getting toward the end of the range of production.

Since we now have this time/serial stake, and a good collection of instruments, lets build up the production record for this company. PM was certainly one of the highest quality and most consistent instrument makers of its' time. Historically, the makers are llineage at least as significant as Thibouville or Buffet. We should be diligent in establishing the historical record of their instruments.
#1368
Photos are definitely helpful. Also it is worth noting that over decades parts can become mixed on these instruments. You obviously have a bell that is for a B-flat "Low Pitch" instrument. The other mark that you list as b#d, is actually the flat symbol, the sharp symbol, and the natural symbol. This appears on all historic Cabart A Paris instruments regardless of key scale until the company was bought and consolidated. it does not designate any particular key model.

Are all the pieces marked with the Cabart A Paris logo? These usually are, and it includes a small sailing ship that you can identify under magnification. This should be present on the barrel, upper joint, lower joint, and bell. If not, you have some mixed parts from other clarinets. Also measuring each part separately will give a better idea of what it is and the definitive measurement is taken from the lowest tone hole to the register key hole.  All the Cabarts I have, including an early Albert keyed one, have the register hole on the back and work with a simple straight lever key. Some photos would help immensely. I have 4 Cabart clarinets from different periods. Earlier on the company was known for professional clarinets. Later after they were acquired they principally made better quality student oboes. In general the value depends on the condition. If the keys all move and the wood has no cracks and all the pieces actually go together, then it is probably worth something to a vintage player / collector.

Lately I have found indications that "Low Pitch" might not mean A=440 Hz. The A=440 Hz. standard was adopted in 1920 by the US government, in 1917 by the American Federation of Musicians. Before that time, there were other standards, two primarily. By French law, the standard was A=435 Hz, and this was in place in 1858 and called "International pitch" even though it was not adopted by law in other countries. Alternatively high pitch was the British Philharmonic standard. A French clarinet marked LP should not be assumed to be A=440 when by French law, A was set at A=435. These are close enough that if the temperature is about 5 degrees warmer, then the 435 clarinet plays closer to A=440 anyway. Details, details.......
#1369
All about Clarinets / Re: Oiling vs Waxing
July 25, 2015, 10:14:43 AM
The Doctor is a great resource on these issues. I like the fact that his approach is generally one of scientific principles and well tested. That is great information.

One thing however, that I have observed with some of the better wooden clarinets is that these are indeed made from one wood blank barrel to bell. On these it is possible to follow grain lines all the way down the instrument. This is usually on the older highest grade instruments. The next grade will have wood that is from one blank except for the bell. This is most wooden clarinets. And then there are those that are wood except for the bell and sometimes the barrel. Wooden clarinets where all the parts are from mixed trees are not that common in the vintage wood pile. I do think his advice is quite good and quite thorough and that the only way to know if the wood needs oil is to give it some and see if it takes it up. These are usually different from clarinet to clarinet and in the vintage category, the maintenance is very much a variable.

I tend to follow the Doctor's procedure for oiling, except that I have found that given a little time, the oil will penetrate all the way from the bore to the exterior if multiple oil treatments are applied to the bore. I do not use a soaking process, just successive light coats. This takes longer but it insures that the process completes and that the wood is still porous throughout the process and still able to exchange moisture. I definitely would not put a sealant on a clarinet exterior. That said, I have two antique clarinets that appear to have had a light shellac finish that is original. One is a Henry Gunckel and the other is a Cabart. Both appear to be turn of the century at the latest.

This is advice from one company regarding oil maintenance. I thought it was quite interesting:
#1370
I am wondering if some of these French stencils with the shared LJ pivot point are Noblet made stencils. You mention Couesnon, which I am not too familiar with. I have a hard rubber Henri Leduc #5620 that is made similar that way and the details of the upper joint key work also match early Noblet key work. Another one I picked up is a wooden Henri Leduc #6900 with similar early Noblet style key work. If these are Noblet clarinets, that might explain why they are pretty good clarinets.

I haven't tested the Leduc pair yet, these need pads and tenon corks, etc. but the key work on both is distinctly early Noblet in style top to bottom.
#1371
All about Clarinets / Re: Diamond in the Rough
July 25, 2015, 09:11:05 AM
I have a G.M. Bundy Paris "SPONSORED BY SELMER" model with the same keywork as this Selmer you just obtained. The case style is the fitted French style with Selmer metal logo on it and the diamond key hole. Similar manufacture date to yours, I'm guessing. The only difference I notice right away is the locking screw on the bottom LJ key post. Otherwise it looks the same.

I am guessing you established the date by serial number? The serials on the G.M. Bundy Paris instruments are usually confusing. This one with the articulated C#/G# key work has two serials, although one appears to have been scratched through. 3940 appears on both joints, but only very lightly on the lower joint, and apparently scratched through on the upper, but this could be due to some wear or damage. Clearly imprinted on the upper edge of the LJ is B270.

It's interesting to see a Selmer that is so similar in details. The Paris made G.M. Bundy clarinets have a reputation for being Selmer "seconds". One wonders exactly what the small differences were. I have 3 of them. One clearly states "Frabrique Par H. Selmer & Cie", one states "SPONSORED BY SELMER", and the other one simply says "Made in France". They are amazingly consistent in wood character and key work quality. The impression from just looking at them is that they would have all come from the same factory.
#1372
All about Clarinets / Re: Single vs double posts
July 25, 2015, 07:45:10 AM
This interests me because I had not previously associated the LJ shared pivot post phenomenon with age alone, except within certain families of makers;- D. Noblet, most notably. I find that there is a very certain alteration of the keywork in many ways and the shift toward unshared LJ pivots is one of these on the D. Noblets at the point in time that the more LeBlanc style of keywork became standard on Noblet clarinets. Essentially these became Noblet branded LeBlancs. At the same time this happens, the upper joint keywork gets a redesign as well. When did this take place? I think it was later than the 20s or else many Noblet clarinets I have seen are older than I thought. I do not think it was simultaneous with LeBlanc's inheritance of the company, but happened some years later. Perhaps they had to use up existing keywork part stock? Perhaps they used the last of the shared post keywork on stenciled brands? I know I speculate, but there are reasons in evidence for these suggestions. When I go through my documentation process thoroughly, I will make sure to note which clarinets have the LJ shared pivot. I have some clarinets well documented photographically. Others not yet. It's an ongoing process. Eventually we should be able to build out timelines with plausible serial ranges for these kinds of details. Clarinet archeology is fascinating.

Why one design became the dominant one is not really that obvious, nor is it something that appears to have happened at the same historical point in every maker that once used the LJ shared pivot post. Certainly for a number of years, the two designs were being offered at the same time. Some makers apparently never used a shared pivot on some models, while other makers used them on the C and Eb models only, and still others it seems to be that less expensive models would have the shared pivot.

The simplest mechanical reasoning would seem to be that if unshared pivot posts are beneficial on the lower joint levers, it would  necessarily follow that unshared posts are beneficial in the the throat levers as well. But in the case of the UJ, the shared pivot for the middle two of the four throat levers is far more common that four separate pivot points. It also appears that historically just as the LJ shared pivot became less common, the shared pivot on the UJ trills became more common. Considerations of the practical differences?

Simplicity of construction, reduction of number of parts, drilling attachment placements.

Mechanical advantage, optimization and balancing of key resistance by providing separate fulcrums

Standardization of keywork design and part interchangeability.

Elegance of design.

It is my opinion that the mechanical reasons were primary. It is also my opinion that the single pivot post is a more elegant reduction of necessary parts;- it contributes to a kind of minimalism in manufacture that I find aesthetically appealing.

Perhaps this is a good thread to present serials, makers, brands, etc. that used the now archaic shared LJ pivot post? We might also track the parallel use of unshared posts in the UJ levers?





#1373
This thread looked short enough to revive as an introduction because I do have an (ahem) harem....

I might be a similar musician to rezzie in that I am primarily a bassist, but I also play trumpet and am diversifying what I can play, including clarinet for a few years.

I started reading Phil's pages a few years ago while researching my first clarinet, a G.M. Bundy Paris (fabrique par H. Selmer & Cie) and became fascinated with the history of all the various makers, stencils, etc. I expanded the "harem" as I became interested in other makers and the differences. Clarinets are gorgeous instruments and while I really enjoy playing trumpet and bass, I have always loved the sound of the clarinet as well. My brother played one of those Bundy plastic clarinets in school and it was a wonderful sound. He was always first chair. Way back then I did learn to play a little bit on his instrument and never had a problem getting a good sound from it, so it is something that has been with me for a long time although I am taking playing more seriously now in my semi-retirement as a musician.

I also had been repairing and restoring vintage guitars for several years, so naturally I began exploring restoring antique clarinets. My harem is large with salvaged fixer-uppers and a few notable players. Currently I am enjoying two different Penzel Mueller Empires and a similar Brilliante and a nice pair of 1940s Conn 424N clarinets. I ended up scoring a B&H Edgware last week that actually came with all the original parts and my favorite after-market mouthpiece, a vintage Vandoren Paris 2RV! I definitely hit the right Edgware! It is a nice Edgware but needs all new pads and a few sticky keys need some adjustment. I will have it playing soon. The harem includes many French stencils as well as name makers and also a good number of vintage American clarinets. Most of these await full restoration, but I have slowed down on N+1 syndrome. My intention is to document the ones I am restoring. No doubt I will send the more deserving ones to Phil for review if he agrees.

Mostly my interest in the "harem" is just seeing the diversity of approaches to keywork, materials, and assisting in building up the lost history of how these forgotten makers and models fit together and promoting clarinet recycling. There are so many old clarinets made of gorgeous wood with great keywork and the tendency of students and new players is to buy uniformly certain new makes and models. I come from the time when musical instrument makers had diverse personalities and I feel like those instruments from that period will also have more diverse personalities (and flaws) than the current situation with consolidated manufacturing. These all have the same presonality and flaws. And apparently Conn-Selmer now includes LeBlanc so we can expect even more future uniformity. Hopefully they do not bite into the poison pitch standard inflation apple.

There is no doubt in my mind that just as I found with vintage guitars that the best wood for clarinets belonged to the first half of the last century, not this one. Recognizing that the materials could only get worse, I decided to concentrate my clarinet efforts on mostly the first half of the 20th century. Composite materials from that period, such as bakelite also are interesting to me and I will probably start collecting some of those as well. Weather proof instruments certainly have utility and I always thought my brother's plastic Bundy sounded really good.

Anyway, I am here to have fun and learn and share information freely. I have posted on Talkbass as well as Trumpetmaster with the same user ID, so you might bump into me on other forums as well.

Thanks to Phil for his very informative Pages and for starting a forum. I feel this is good company.  :)