I don't think it's weird, Larry. It is a case of "whatever works", regardless of name, status, or history of the MP. As the donor of your Noblet MP, I am not disappointed. It is a good standard of comparison, so if it demonstrated that the 4C is optimum for you, then you may enjoy it with added confidence.
MPs are not only highly personal, but also they also vary within any given brand and model. Rejoice!